Can a renovation in Ottawa use less insulation to match old framing?
Can a renovation in Ottawa use less insulation to match old framing?
Yes, Ontario's Building Code has a compliance alternative that allows this in specific circumstances. It is called C207, and it applies where framing systems are being altered to match the existing framing.
What C207 says
The Building Code's Part 11 governs renovations to existing buildings. The general rule under 11.3.1.1.(1) is that where an existing building system is materially altered or repaired, its performance afterward shall be at least equal to its performance before the work. C207, found in Table 11.5.1.1.-C, creates a specific relief from that rule: where the framing systems are being altered to match the existing framing, lesser amounts and extent of insulation and vapour barrier are acceptable.
That is the part of C207 that applies here. It does not name an R-value floor, and it does not apply to every renovation, only to work where the framing is being matched to what was already there.
The Code's energy standard for housing, SB-12, sets minimum insulation values for new houses and additions in Ottawa. Those values do not apply to an existing house being renovated under Part 11, and we found no Code number that sets a minimum R-value for voluntarily topping up insulation in an existing home.
Part 11 also includes 11.3.1.2.(1), which says a new building system, or the extension of an existing one, must comply with the other Parts of the Code, with some relief through compliance alternatives. So if the renovation introduces something genuinely new rather than matching what was there, C207 may not be the right path.
A few things to sort out before relying on C207:
- The work must involve altering framing systems to match existing framing. A contractor or designer needs to confirm the scope fits that description.
- The vapour barrier relief is part of the same alternative, so the vapour barrier may also be matched to what was there rather than brought up to new-house standards.
- Insulation on its own is not named on the City of Ottawa's permit lists. Where the renovation also involves removing or adding walls, structural repairs, or other listed work, a permit question arises and the City's Building Code Services is the right place to ask.
Before you sign anything with a contractor for this job, ask them to show you in writing exactly which Code clause or compliance alternative covers the insulation and vapour barrier approach they are proposing, and whether they have confirmed that interpretation with the City.
Want this done at your place?
Tell us which part of the house you want insulated and we'll send it to local Ottawa insulation contractors, who reply by email. We send it out to local contractors for you. Free, no pressure.
R-Value IQ -- Built from the Ontario Building Code, Ontario regulations and City of Ottawa sources and real construction experience. Answers are for informational purposes only and are not a professional assessment.
Ready to Get Quotes?
Find local insulation contractors in Ottawa. Free matching, no obligation.